Michael Earp - This Thing We Called Love

Image by Teague Leigh

2026 Hot Desk Extract

As part of The Wheeler Centre’s Hot Desk Fellowship program, Michael Earp worked on their travel memoir, This Thing We Called Love. Chronicling Michael’s literal and spiritual journey in search of healing, it unpacks a 15-year long abusive relationship from a dramatically underrepresented queer perspective. Driving over 16,000kms around the USA with their trans-masc partner and trans-fem best friend, the trio reimagines the conceptual journey taken by the title character of Tori Amos’ 2002 album, Scarlet’s Walk. An annotated playlist and travelogue, heart-breaking and heart-warming, it gives voice to survivors of abuse where hearts are bruised when bodies are not.

Part 1

'A Sorta Fairytale'

San Francisco ~ Yosemite ~ San Francisco

Tuesday, June 7th, 2022

♪ 'Road' / Lane 8 feat. Arctic Lake / Brightest Lights (2020)

The San Francisco skyline appears as we drive towards it on the 101.
‘I’ve been here before,’ I say with a flash of nostalgia, more to myself than to the others.
Twenty-two years ago, I was sixteen and visiting the United States with my family. The buildings must have changed from the last time I saw them, but approaching the city from the airport calls that trip to mind in an instant. 
I had been a closeted teen in one of the gayest cities in the world, desperate for experience, petrified of my family seeing me for who I was. On our walking tour of Alcatraz, I surreptitiously followed a gay couple with the audacity to hold hands; the first time I’d ever seen queer PDA. I discovered Tom of Finland via a well-browsed book in the Virgin Records Megastore sale bin and secretly poured over it, scandalised and titillated by hypermasculine pencil-drawn erotica. The world was bursting with things I was yet to encounter and so far from understanding. 
In response to my statement, Bayley asks, ‘You’ve queued for nearly three hours for a hire car at San Fran Airport before?’
I give her a deadpan stare, but her eyes are on the road. I can tell she’s nervous about driving on the right-hand side, her recently auburn hair a bit dishevelled from nineteen hours’ transit.
Travis speaks from the back, peering out the windscreen through the seats. ‘Well, I’ve never been here. Plenty of other places, but never San Fran.’ He had never wanted to return to America after three hellish teenage years in Ohio; his military father with family in tow. This wild concept of a road trip tempted him back — for photography, for me. 
Travis says, ‘My hands are already itching to get out my camera.’
‘There’ll be plenty of time for your official duties,’ Bayley says, as if they’re both my self-appointed support staff. Being centred in that way makes me uncomfortable, but I’m learning to accept their teasing.
If Travis is the trip’s photographer, Bayley tells people she’s here as driver, completely downplaying her creative motivations to write her own poetry collection. She was determined to join me on this trip from the moment she heard me speak of it, before I knew Travis. Long drives are nothing for her, so why not do a lap of the fourth-largest country in the world?

On the night that Bayley and I met, I was at a party I hadn’t planned on attending. The group I was with went to find 1am kebabs. The conversation turned to how one person thought that not liking the singer P!nk was a dumpable offence. At that moment, our footpath congregation was split in two by passing pedestrians and I was alone with this person I’d barely spoken to.
She said, ‘The only singer I’d dump someone over is Tori Amos.’
My mind spun. Surely someone wouldn’t dislike Tori so much as to randomly single her out.
‘Oh my god,’ I said. ‘I have a Tori Amos lyric tattoo. It’s in her handwriting.’
She looked at me with a seriousness I’ll never forget and said, ‘So do I.’
We dated for a wonderful handful of months in a time she refers to as ‘a whole gender ago’. But it was her leaving — me, and the country — to chase her dream career as a consent educator that sent me on a sex rampage that led me right to Travis. 
On my first date with Travis, I was thrilled he had Tori CDs in his collection. He also recognised the words on my bicep for what they were: a Tori lyric, a declaration on how important trust and honesty are to me. On other occasions, I’d been asked by guys at bars if the phrase was kink related. I’d enjoyed shutting down the conversation by saying, ‘No, I got it the first time my ex went to prison.’ With Travis, though, my bold (some would say questionable) choice to lay all my trauma on the table that first date was met head on, truth for truth.

I’m putting my life on hold to chase a character from Tori Amos’ concept album Scarlet’s Walk around a foreign country 20 years after its release. It’s also 20 years since, at 18, I was groomed into a relationship fraught with interpersonal abuses. None of them were physical abuses, so I didn’t see them for what they were. Can two months on the road really provide any clarity?
All the things that brought me here, all the emotional baggage; now’s the time to unpack them. I’ve been holding it all at arm’s length for the five years since I left ‘The Sheriff’— the epithet I’m giving my ex borrowed from the album’s titular song. I amassed so much baggage during the 15 years we were together. 
At least I’m with the two people closest to me in the world; I can trust them with my mess as we follow the map laid out by Scarlet, song by song, along its lines around America.
Bayley says, ‘I’m starving!’ 
Travis agrees. ‘Dinner in the Castro is scheduled right after we’ve checked in.’
It’s pride month. PDAs are commonplace in the queer neighbourhood — couples hold hands or kiss in greeting. 
The air is warm and weighty, different to a Melbourne summer; a world away from the winter we left behind only yesterday/today. Businesses like ‘Hand-Job Nails & Spa’ and ‘Hot Cookie’ give us a chuckle, and we eat at ‘Harvey’s’, one of the oldest bars in the area. Opened in 1874 as ‘Elephant Walk’, it was renamed to honour Harvey Milk, assassinated for his fight for justice and equality. The staff are friendly, serving up the first, ‘Oh, where y’all from?’ of the trip. The fried chicken and mash are rich and delicious.
Emerging from dinner into the early dark, rainbows are everywhere. The roads are painted with them, The Castro Theatre is lit up in technicolour, and there’s more rainbow bunting than you can shake a glow stick at. After a nightcap at Twin Peaks Tavern, we return to The Cow Hollow Inn, the modest motel we booked on the other side of Pacific Heights.
‘Now we’ve eaten, I need sleep,’ Travis says. 
I agree… one thing at a time.