If you missed it, you can catch up on this recording or you can listen to this podcast.


Intelligence Squared Debates

View all events in this series

at Melbourne Town Hall

“There is No Justification for Risking Australian Lives in Afghanistan”

As each name is added to the growing list of Australians killed serving in Afghanistan, the government assures the nation that the sacrifice in lives has been for a good cause and in the national interest. But what is the national interest that justifies such a terrible cost? Is this the price of our alliance with the United States? Is this the price of helping to curb the terrorist threat? Is this the price of national honour? Some believe that the price must be paid in the service of such causes. Yet others find no consolation in claims of national interest; condemning the loss of Australian lives far from home.

Arguing for the proposition will be Kellie Tranter, Raoul Heinrichs and Eva Cox. Arguing against the proposition will be Sonia Ziaee, Jim Molan and Peter Singer.

Add to calendar


Portrait of Kellie Tranter

Kellie Tranter

Kellie Tranter is a lawyer and commentator who ran as an Independent candidate for the NSW seat of Maitland.

Portrait of Peter Singer

Peter Singer

Peter Singer is a philosopher and author of over 25 books on ethics. He is best known for Animal Liberation, widely credited with starting the animal rights movement.

Portrait of Raoul Heinrichs

Raoul Heinrichs

Raoul Heinrichs is a scholar, editor of the Lowy Institute’s Strategic Snapshots and former foreign and security adviser to Kevin Rudd while in opposition.

Portrait of Eva Cox

Eva Cox

Eva Cox has been an academic, political adviser, public servant, and runs a small research and policy consultancy. A sociologist by trade, she promotes ideas widely and eclectically in books, on line, in journals and other media.

Portrait of Sonia Ziaee

Sonia Ziaee

Sonia Ziaee is an Afghani businesswoman, Flinders University student, and Afghani student community activist.

Portrait of Jim Molan

Jim Molan

Jim Molan is a retired major-general of the Australian armed forces who, from 2004, oversaw a multinational force of some 300,000 troops in Iraq as the country undertook the first democratic elections after the fall of Saddam Hussein.

Intelligence Squared Debates

The Intelligence Squared debates rage on in 2014 with a whole new range of topics as compelling as they are polarising. In these highly participatory debates, once both sides have had their say, the decision as to who emerges victor lies entirely in your hands.


More about this venue, including large map, parking, public transport and accessibility.

Presented in partnership with